Powerchairs vs Manual Wheelchairs

When it comes to choosing the right wheelchair for your needs, it’s important to choose one that not only suits your lifestyle but one that’s affordable and within your budget as well. Both manual and electric wheelchairs have their pros and cons, and which one you decide to choose will depend on your own specific needs. What works for some may not work for you, for example, someone suffering from MS will need something more specialised than someone who may be recovering from a spinal injury, and so you need to be sure that a wheelchair is right for you before purchasing.

In many cases, your doctor or carer will be able to help you with any questions you have in regards to the right chair, however, it’s always best to do some research if possible, especially if you’re considering whether to buy an electric wheelchair or a manual wheelchair. Below are some factors to consider when choosing the wheelchair for you, and some pros and cons to both.

What is a power wheelchair?

A power wheelchair is power-assisted and allows you to move with ease. It’s perfect if you struggle with weak arms, and comes with options for tilting, reclining and standing if you need it. They are usually controlled by a joystick which gives you control.

What is a manual wheelchair?

A manual wheelchair is pushed by either yourself or a carer and can be used for travel, everyday use, or for use around the house. They’re usually cheaper than electric wheelchairs and can be used by a range of users such as those recovering from an injury.

Cost differences

In terms of costs, manual wheelchairs are less expensive than electric wheelchairs and are cheaper to insure as well. If you only need a wheelchair in the short term, then a manual wheelchair may be the best option for you. However, if your needs are more complex and you require additional assistance, then an electric wheelchair may be better for you in terms of comfort and ease of use.

Ease of use

Although electric wheelchairs can offer easier ease of use than a manual wheelchair can when it comes to portability and transportation, the manual wheelchair wins. It can be collapsed, easily stored and can be put under beds or cupboards when the time comes.

That being said, there are some electric wheelchairs that can be disassembled and stored as well. However, these may not be easily collapsed due to their weight and size, so consider how often you will need to transport it and or/collapse it before making a decision on the right wheelchair for you.

Ease of access

While accessibility is always improving, it’s also true that navigating public spaces in a wheelchair can still be difficult. Raised curbs, incorrectly installed ramps and narrow spaces can be hard to navigate for manual wheelchairs, whereas electric wheelchairs can give you enough power to overcome obstacles. Although, if you do end up becoming stuck whilst in an electric wheelchair, then it may be harder to free yourself especially if you’re alone. You’ll also need to consider its battery life when in public, as losing energy in a public space may cause you to become stranded.

Independence

If independence is one of the main factors in your decision to choose either a manual or electric wheelchair, then ask yourself whether you can use a manual wheelchair alone when you need it. If the answer is no, then an electric wheelchair may be a better option for you as it can allow more freedom and support for day-to-day activities.

Maintenance

Between a manual and an electric wheelchair, an electric wheelchair will require more maintenance than a manual one. You will need to recharge the battery on a regular basis, and even replace the battery when needed.

Powerchairs vs Manual Wheelchairs

The decision between a manual and a powerchair can be a tough one to make, and for many, the answer isn’t simple. Every individual has certain needs, and you must choose the right chair that caters to them in the best way. Always consult your doctor or carer before making a decision, and be sure to ask yourself which type of wheelchair will benefit you the most in terms of ease of use, independence, and budget. You can check out our manual wheelchairs here and our powerchairs here.

wheelchair for your needs, it’s important to choose one that not only suits your lifestyle but one that’s affordable and within your budget as well. Both manual and electric wheelchairs have their pros and cons, and which one you decide to choose will depend on your own specific needs. What works for some may not work for you, for example, someone suffering from MS will need something more specialised than someone who may be recovering from a spinal injury, and so you need to be sure that a wheelchair is right for you before purchasing.